Your character name:
Their character name: Bill Carson
Their Byond key (optional - if you know it): Fitchace
Approximate time and date of the incident (Central US Time for fastest results): Almost literally any round they play
What rule(s) were broken: ...Strictly speaking, none.
Description of the incident: A consistent history of excessively poor performance in all command roles, including CO and Queen, and the fact that it happens nearly every round they play the aforementioned roles.
Evidence (screenshots, logs, etc): Just... Look at the logs for any round they're commander. Christ.
The round before the current one, Bill was commander for all of 10 minutes before ordering an immediate abandoning of the planet (which had an exceedingly solid and defensible FOB established) for a "rebriefing". This resulted almost directly in the loss of the round for the marines, as we lost our foothold on the planet rather quickly. There was absolutely no reason for the order to have been given, etc.
10 minutes as commander, already got a mutiny against him with ~15 marines directly participating in the mutiny, and 90% of the others supporting it.
That should say something.
It's not the first time they've had a mutiny against them, and they're just... I want to say they're an idiot, but that's not necessarily true. They're a decent player, etc, but they absolutely should not be in command roles of any sort.
How you would punish the accused: Job Ban from CO/XO/BO/Queen, to be gradually lifted up the chain of command if they show that they can be an effective squad leader/marine.
Edit to include supplemental imagery:
