Thor's will

[Frans_Feiffer]

-1

I don’t want to be a party pooper, but as stated this app shows no effort, and while you’re responses to questioning are pretty decent, if you had put the time into your app rather then making it into a meme, then you’d have my +1. But I tend to look at these apps with a little more respect and not just give +1s to those who put no effort into said app, just because they play command roles. If you’re not going to put effort into making a good app, then how can I tell you’ll put effort into being a worthwhile CO?

Sorry if that came off rude or anything. I just don’t want to see an app like this be accepted. In a month if you can put the effort into another app, you’ll sure as hell have my +1. I’ve seen you ingame and you’re not bad, but this is beyond the minimum of what should be tolerable for someone wanting to actually be accepted.

[awan]

The Commander whitelist is a filter out for BRs and that is mostly what it is used for when it comes to literacy, stratagem, etc. A Commander's main skill is communication and I am extremely vocal over the Command comms for morale, orders and keeping my men updated on everything going on in the field.

I do disagree with this because the readme section says they are held to higher standards. A commander should be an example to all marines. And not just not a br/baldie.

If you look at my notes, I have few to no malicious notes at all. All of my notes either come from boredom or trying something new, or something was just interpreted incorrectly. I have no notes of went around and murdered fifteen marines and then went SSD. Some of them are retaliatory as well. I have no issues regarding staff besides some few people who I think dislike me.

I don't want to go into specific notes of players when it is not an appeal or something moderation related.
If you think staff members dislike you/are unfair you can always bring it up to a manager.
I can say there is no grief in your notes. I do not want to give off that impression and do want to make sure no one thinks that.

I'll be real, it's a whitelist, I'm not psychotic and going to whip my Mateba around just blasting it at the RO because he denied me a BC for my Mateba.

Meh, this is opinion based and I think you are mistaken if you think it is easy for a commander to behave/not take stuff to far.
Even aceluke has had issues someone who I think is one of the best mods.

Me playing a PFC separate from other roles is extremely different. I can do every single role on the ship, have never been player reported before because I can't be bothered to grief that badly and am just well versed in the community of CM. I know the community and how everything works, if people just test me for being Asmodius like they do Heinz, similar retaliatory action will be taken.

The retaliatory action is exactly what I am afraid off. The entire soyboi thing is something I have utter disdain off. And something I would not like to see repeated if possible.

Commander was never really the hardest whitelist to get, it always came down to someone playing XO and SO like four rounds and apping. Just look at Omicega's app, have you ever actually seen them play XO or SO? They apped for Commander and still got it, which should tell you a little something about the whitelist. I play Command on a different character, Antonnio Popillii Laenates. He refers to the Commander as Legate, the XO, himself as Laticlavius, SOs stay Lieutenants and there are different ranking for which the squads are divided into.

It might not have been the hardest but I myself still think that standards that might have already been low are at a lowpoint for cm. (Except for when they hired Bill Carson. (JK))
Overal you dont need my +1 and I think we can agree to disagree. Opinions are there to be diffrent.

[ThesoldierLLJK]

I don’t actually mind the Roman quirk because we have a absolute madman who role plays as a royal lord who thinks it’s still 1499

I agree with others the application had no effort put into it, but I only gave a plus one cause I’ve seen Thor plenty of times and he knows how the game works.

After all the intent of the CO whitelist is to weed out a baldie, but I really think you’re gonna have to earn this one Thor because as I said people who have been around longer than you put more effort into their applications and didn’t treat it as carefree as you did.

If any of you think his application is low effort, do what I did and give him some questions

[BluntForce420]

+1 spent like 3 minutes on it last night lmao

[Nightwolf901]

+1 I know this man and the App was straight to the point.

[TheDonkified]

is this loss. +1 because this is to filter baldies and i've seen antonnio rp as an exorcist.

[driecg36]

the application is hot garbage, low effort, and I can't remember the last time I've seen thor in a command role.

I've seen you play a shit ton and you're mostly not retarded tho, so just re answer "Why should we whitelist you" and "What do you think the job of a commander is" in a way that shows brain activity and I'll prolly +1 you.

[Survivor]

I'm gonna +1 because I've seen you a good amount in game, but seriously... the second lowest effort app I've ever seen.

I'm amazed you've gotten this much support with such a terrible app. It would be even better if you took longer than two minutes to answer each question.

[LittleBlast]

-1, If you can't bother to put the extra 10 minutes into writing a proper application then I do not want you a Commander.

[Asmodius]

-1, If you can't bother to put the extra 10 minutes into writing a proper application then I do not want you a Commander.

Your feedback is greatly appreciated.

[Asmodius]

the application is hot garbage, low effort, and I can't remember the last time I've seen thor in a command role.

I've seen you play a shit ton and you're mostly not retarded tho, so just re answer "Why should we whitelist you" and "What do you think the job of a commander is" in a way that shows brain activity and I'll prolly +1 you.

Why should we whitelist you?

I have a pulse and a lot of hours put into CM as a game and community. I'm active on Discord and in game. My presence in game is known to everyone and I am able to do literally everything on the ship, my skillset being through the roof when it comes to robustness and skill knowledge (ie: Medical, Engineering, Req). There are several times when I have assumed control after the Commander whitelisted themselves as Commander just to get a free guaranteed Smartgun and lead the Marines to victory against the threat at hand.

English is also my first language.

What do you think the job of a Commander is?

A good Commander should be able to fill the roles of all shipside crew and associated aspects besides the expertise that comes along with those roles, read: Surgery, Engineering. He should also be adept at Communication as I believe his ID is the only one to access announcements besides the XO. A Commander's word should be trusted and assumed that he knows the best for his crew, to make smaller sacrifices instead of larger ones to achieve a similar or the same effect. A Commander should be able to keep his crew and ship under control without causing mutiny, havoc or distrust within the groundside forces.

[driecg36]

I have a pulse and a lot of hours put into CM as a game and community. I'm active on Discord and in game. My presence in game is known to everyone and I am able to do literally everything on the ship, my skillset being through the roof when it comes to robustness and skill knowledge (ie: Medical, Engineering, Req). There are several times when I have assumed control after the Commander whitelisted themselves as Commander just to get a free guaranteed Smartgun and lead the Marines to victory against the threat at hand.

English is also my first language.


A good Commander should be able to fill the roles of all shipside crew and associated aspects besides the expertise that comes along with those roles, read: Surgery, Engineering. He should also be adept at Communication as I believe his ID is the only one to access announcements besides the XO. A Commander's word should be trusted and assumed that he knows the best for his crew, to make smaller sacrifices instead of larger ones to achieve a similar or the same effect. A Commander should be able to keep his crew and ship under control without causing mutiny, havoc or distrust within the groundside forces.

good answers

so +1

[NethIafins]

No effort in the app. While your later answers are good, in my opinion it shows that you are only good when asked about stuff, while commander should be good in LEADING stuff

-1

[Clutch]

yaass queen slay +1

[Asmodius]

No effort in the app. While your later answers are good, in my opinion it shows that you are only good when asked about stuff, while commander should be good in LEADING stuff

-1

All of the questions in the original application format can be answered with a simple yes or no. The others can be answered with a simple sentence or two revolving around the subject.

Unless you actually wanted me to write out a sentence that said, "I understand that the Commander is not above Marine Law and I will not play as such--," that's basically implied when I put yes as an answer. There's physically no need for me to type out a paragraph that says I understand that the Commander is not above Marine Law, or literally any other relevant subject. Zane already posted something similar to this in his application.

No one has -1'ed me for having incorrect answers or my play style being incorrect, just low effort. The closest thing was Awan having a different opinion but that's about it. I'm versed in Commander, I've played WITH many Commanders, I know many Commanders, I play Command and all of the above.

The application isn't wrong per say, the questions were answered in a low word count and all following questions answered in a detailed way. If you really want to look at my Commander app in that manner, then take the answers I supplied for Driecg, and put them where the original application was, or literally any other question I've answered. Three of the questions are literally yes/no.

[LittleBlast]

All of the questions in the original application format can be answered with a simple yes or no. The others can be answered with a simple sentence or two revolving around the subject.

Can be done does not mean should be done. The app doesn't have to be an essay, but it should have even a semblance of effort put into it.

Telling us to use the later answers is like handing in the paper again 3 days after it's due. It may be perfect, but it wasn't done on time, so you really can't expect full credit. Especially when there was no time you needed this in by.

[Frans_Feiffer]

All of the questions in the original application format can be answered with a simple yes or no. The others can be answered with a simple sentence or two revolving around the subject.

Unless you actually wanted me to write out a sentence that said, "I understand that the Commander is not above Marine Law and I will not play as such--," that's basically implied when I put yes as an answer. There's physically no need for me to type out a paragraph that says I understand that the Commander is not above Marine Law, or literally any other relevant subject. Zane already posted something similar to this in his application.

No one has -1'ed me for having incorrect answers or my play style being incorrect, just low effort. The closest thing was Awan having a different opinion but that's about it. I'm versed in Commander, I've played WITH many Commanders, I know many Commanders, I play Command and all of the above.

The application isn't wrong per say, the questions were answered in a low word count and all following questions answered in a detailed way. If you really want to look at my Commander app in that manner, then take the answers I supplied for Driecg, and put them where the original application was, or literally any other question I've answered. Three of the questions are literally yes/no.

I get that, but if you had just put the time into making a good application, then we wouldn’t have to have asked
You questions in the first place. Without something more then a yes, we have nothing to base you off of asides the fact that you’ll do the bare minimum, which doesn’t give a good impression. As Commander you’re supposed to put effort into it, show you’re willing to do something even if it is a little redundant. We’re not asking for a perfect app with multiple paragraphs for each answer, we just want something that shows you put time into it, so we have something more then yes and yes to base your character off of.

[ThesoldierLLJK]

I think the other problem is you have a list of people who have been waiting more than a month who put more effort into theirs than you did. Kinda a slap in the face to them, but I only gave a +1 because I know you can do it. If you were just joe blow who did this, it would have been a -1 all day long.

Good luck

[Asmodius]

I think the other problem is you have a list of people who have been waiting more than a month who put more effort into theirs than you did. Kinda a slap in the face to them, but I only gave a +1 because I know you can do it. If you were just joe blow who did this, it would have been a -1 all day long.

Good luck

See, look at Awans app who got it accepted extremely quickly even with the community being slightly divided on it. However, Survivors is still being processed without a single downvote and it has been up for twice as long. This will be my last post on the app for things not regarding the application itself, I'm still answering questions.

[carlarc]

i will exert the same effort that it took to make this app in my response

-1

[DriedMilk]

Neutral leaning to negative.

I have seen you as XO, although I don't remember how well or bad you did.

Leaning to negative due to the bareboneness of the application itself.

[nerocavalier]

-1. A lot of the negative feedback could have been prevented if you had actually just put in effort into the first post. Sure, you had good answers when prompted but you didn't want to try before that.

[Jakkkk]

As much as I like you Thor, low quality applications just show that the person is so assured of receiving the whitelist that they don't give a damn about actually trying for it. I don't stand for that.

-1 chief.

[ChengChan]

I don't understand if this is a shitpost or not but I don't see you in command since you went a lower rank role. No effort application. -1

[VortexGaming]

Unless you actually wanted me to write out a sentence that said, "I understand that the Commander is not above Marine Law and I will not play as such--," that's basically implied when I put yes as an answer. There's physically no need for me to type out a paragraph that says I understand that the Commander is not above Marine Law, or literally any other relevant subject. Zane already posted something similar to this in his application.

when you said zane already said something similar to this, He realized that although people knowing he can do it with a shitty app it's still a kick in the gut so he withdrew. The app is literally bare bones and though I know you can do it I would wish for something that shows a bit more effort. changing from neutral to -1