Denied suggestions page.

[Kryfrac]

Summary
I suggest we add a seperate sub topic below accepted suggestions that all locked/denied suggeations are added to.
Benifits
Easier navigation of currently active auggestions.
Details
As said, A new subtopic should be added below accepted suggestions, named "Denied Suggestions" in which all denied suggestions automatically archive to.
This would allow for easy navigation of current suggestions and perhaps people should have to read not only accepted suggestions but also denied suggestions before posting.

[Wesmas]

You mean like this place? http://colonial-marines.com/viewforum.php?f=86

[MrGabol100]

You mean like this place? http://colonial-marines.com/viewforum.php?f=86

That also includes accepted suggestions and resolved bugs.

[LordLoko]

You mean like this place? http://colonial-marines.com/viewforum.php?f=86

Isn't that for Resolved (e.i Implemented) suggestion?

[Wesmas]

You both may be right. I am unsure.

[Lostmixup]

I wouldn't be opposed to splitting the archive area into "resolved accepted suggestions" and "resolved denied suggestions" or something. Would make it easier for people to check to see if a suggestion's been tried before or not (rip macho man randy savage event).

[Wesmas]

I wouldn't be opposed to splitting the archive area into "resolved accepted suggestions" and "resolved denied suggestions" or something. Would make it easier for people to check to see if a suggestion's been tried before or not (rip macho man randy savage event).

That sounds sensible to me.

[monkeysfist101]

Yep. +1

[forwardslashN]

+1
Excellent idea.

[qsleepy]

+1 like it

[Tristan63]

-1 To be honest all it would be used for is making fun of the people who suggested it, regardless of how good it is.

[Arachnidnexus]

A list of denied suggestions also means that we can't have discussion on things that were denied but might be good suggestions because the game itself has changed. For example, breaching used to be allowed and doctors having access to guns was forbidden until people kept discussing those changes. Eventually breaching was forbidden again and now doctors have the ability to defend themselves.

On the other hand, we do get a lot of duplicate suggestions that happen because nobody checks the suggestion forum, but I feel that people who don't read other suggestions will ignore the "Denied Suggestions" as well.

[Lostmixup]

A list of denied suggestions also means that we can't have discussion on things that were denied but might be good suggestions because the game itself has changed. For example, breaching used to be allowed and doctors having access to guns was forbidden until people kept discussing those changes. Eventually breaching was forbidden again and now doctors have the ability to defend themselves.

On the other hand, we do get a lot of duplicate suggestions that happen because nobody checks the suggestion forum, but I feel that people who don't read other suggestions will ignore the "Denied Suggestions" as well.

I don't see how having a list of denied suggestions will make it impossible to have a discussion about said denied suggestions. If anything, it'd make it easier to talk about them because good denied suggestions would be easier to find.

[Arachnidnexus]

I don't see how having a list of denied suggestions will make it impossible to have a discussion about said denied suggestions. If anything, it'd make it easier to talk about them because good denied suggestions would be easier to find.

People are just going to use the "already denied" to stop discussion. If you don't believe me check out some of the denied suggestions.

[Lostmixup]

People are just going to use the "already denied" to stop discussion. If you don't believe me check out some of the denied suggestions.

If they're already doing it, then doing this won't really change much.

[apophis775]

Denied.

Anything that gets denied, gets sent to the resolved archive. I'm not making a denied suggestions area, I see no reason to populate a forum with ideas that we basically decided were bad.